Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

vote strut tower brace or no???

Collapse
X
Collapse
Who has read this thread:
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • vote strut tower brace or no???

    welll from reading what people think that it doesnt do any thing for the 100$ i just want to tell my opinnion and think its a great mod and helps out lots with my body roll and cornering
    72
    yes for strut tower brace
    80.56%
    58
    NO
    19.44%
    14

  • #2
    I have one, never gained anything from it. To me it is an appearance mod and not a suspension mod.
    ------------------------------------------
    2004 GMC Envoy - Tuned, Airraid Intake, rest stock
    2005 Malibu - Stock, anyone have a ecotec factory gm supercharger for me? lol

    5th gen Camaro V6 Forums
    http://www.bowtiev6.com

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by motownZ View Post
      welll from reading what people think that it doesnt do any thing for the 100$ i just want to tell my opinnion and think its a great mod and helps out lots with my body roll and cornering
      STB's will do nothing for body roll.
      sigpic
      Turbo Charged LS1/T56

      Comment


      • #4
        I've been wondering about the same thing but I bought one anyways. Oh well, either way. I saw one on my W-Impala, I figure GM doesn't spend money on parts that really isn't needed, so I figure it has to do something.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by willasc View Post
          I've been wondering about the same thing but I bought one anyways. Oh well, either way. I saw one on my W-Impala, I figure GM doesn't spend money on parts that really isn't needed, so I figure it has to do something.
          I worked on w-car for quite a while and we actually measured loads in that tower-tower brace. It wasn't much of anything. So we got rid of it on the new w-cars. Some vehicles have them that don't need them, and some do need them. Sometimes it depends on what the vehicle chief wants, even if it doesn't make sense.

          The purpose is just as a brace. On our cars since the towers are not tied into the rest of the body structure very well I think it does increase the stiffness and does help brace the towers. I don't have data to show this. It can't help body roll or anything, just stiffens the towers.

          Brian

          Comment


          • #6
            the car feels more solid hitting speed bumps, doesnt creak as much but thats about it. I can feel that its there, but as far as a handling gain... no not really. I got mine used cause it wasnt worth that much to me either.
            -Joel
            1995 Z28 M6 - AI226/234 - autocross ricer
            1984 Scottsdale K10 - 305/4bbl/4spd


            WTB List:Midwest Chasis DS Loop

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by 97rs4life View Post
              I have one, never gained anything from it. To me it is an appearance mod and not a suspension mod.
              Agreed.. Made no diff on my car..
              sigpic
              U.S. Army 1983-2005
              11.20@122.37 1.51 60'

              Originally posted by WMCCjames

              "Plans Subject to change upon Sobering up"

              Comment


              • #8
                They look nice to me!

                Comment


                • #9
                  new sway bars would be a better bet but they(strut tower braces) do look cool
                  sigpic
                  Sold!
                  www.fquick.com/lozanoa11
                  94 Grand Cherokee (sold)
                  95 Accord(for sale)
                  99 Outback (snow destroyer)

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    ive used strut bars on most of my talons/eclipses and have always liked them. not sure how much of a difference they make, but it cant hurt, plus i got mine for free. (thanks larry)
                    sigpic
                    11.84 @ 117 w 1.66 60' (previous na best)

                    - - 5.3/4L80e/T7875 - -
                    - Huron Speed Turbo Kit -

                    1998 Formula

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      the STB does nothing for body roll, nor does it help with handling..

                      it is for high HP uses to help keep the car straight and the frame from twisting.

                      -Im Ron Burgundy?
                      ----------------------------
                      -LT1 383 Stroker, 36 lbs SVO's, Comp Custom grind, Eagle H beam forged rotating assembly, 1.5 RR's, Hooker super comp LT's, custom straight pipes back to a pair of Thrush Turbo II's.. more to come.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        i vote do it just because it makes the engine bay look a lot better i think. i doubt it does much if anything for performance

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Have the Hotchkis polished one on the '01. Looks great. Car seems to follow ruts in the road a lot less after we installed it
                          '73 Z28 388 Stroker, M22 Rockcrusher 4 speed
                          WMCC Photographer and owner of Redline Photography
                          You are only young once but you can be immature your whole life!!!
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Make some power then worry about a stb. do subframes tighten her up a bit..

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I think that on the 4th gens the STB isnt as big of a deal, but on the 3rd gens it seems we suffer from a lot more flex. Especially when considering drivers of my weight class. For typical street driving an STB isnt going to provide much benifit, but when you start dancing with the curves is when the STB starts to show. Most people think of them as a simple brace, but when you start thinking about driving on that unseen edge and the predictability of your ride, thats when the STB's become necessary. They are a great addition to help with predictability. Any flex at all is going to change suspension geometry and because of that, its more difficult to push the car to that invisible edge and maintain it. but once that flex is removed you can really push the car KNOWING where the edge is and KNOWING its not going to change. No it doesnt remove all variables, but to remove even one variable from the equation is a huge benefit in my book. I am one of the poorest people on this board probably and yet I have made it a point to get an STB for my car.

                              Most people dont remember the problems with 3rd gens especially in the early years. Did you know there is actually a GM TSB for the early 3rd gens which was to address stress cracks on the inner strut tower caused by tower flex. Did you know the only thing GM recommended is to weld up the crack and nothing more. Sure sounds like a half ass attempt to cover up a problem becuase they didnt want to admit that the car was a structural nightmare. The 3rd gens, ESPECIALLY the early years, NEED an STB. There are no doubts in my mind. After reading that one STB which is scary as hell, considering the stress crack is on a component which is vital for vehicle control and performance. GM designers should have taken the blame and fixed the problem properly instead of throwing a bandaid on it.

                              If anyone is curious of the TSB then go to firebirdnation.com and look for it in the tech article section where I placed it. Just search my username and you can find it that way too.

                              And one more thing, if GM had stress crack problems on the early 3rd gens, do you really think the rest are much if any better? Which the suspension rework for 4th gens I dont think they have the same issues, but I wouldnt be surprised if they do. GM has always had a habit of hiding problems instead of addressing them.
                              Last edited by hgffrank; June 24th, 2007, 01:29 PM.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X